• Question: are we alone in the universe

    Asked by Jay E-Vans to Ceri, Marikka, Matt, Rob, Sally on 14 Nov 2014. This question was also asked by St Cyres Wales, sdkfz 222.
    • Photo: Sally Cutler

      Sally Cutler answered on 14 Nov 2014:


      Hi, Afraid I don’t know.

    • Photo: Ceri Dare

      Ceri Dare answered on 15 Nov 2014:


      Nobody knows – we haven’t heard from intelligent aliens yet, and if aliens existed, I think they would be so different that we wouldn’t even understand what they were.

    • Photo: Matt Bilton

      Matt Bilton answered on 17 Nov 2014:


      This is a quote from the Hitchikers Guide to the Galaxy:

      “Space,” it says, “is big. Really big. You just won’t believe how vastly, hugely, mindbogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it’s a long way down the road to the chemist’s, but that’s just peanuts to space, listen…”

      I think that the chances of there being some sort of life elsewhere in the universe, given the size of the universe…is pretty high. We know it is possible for life to arise at least once in the universe after all, because we are the proof.

      If once – why not more times?

      Much research into the beginnings of life is based on the repeating the sorts of conditions that may have been present on Earth, before life. Chemical reactions that can produce molecules important for life, like nucleic acids (that form RNA and DNA), amino acids (that form proteins) and fatty acids (that form fats – important for cell membranes) are not that hard to imagine happening elsewhere, maybe on a distant planet that looks like earth. And these sorts of molecules could very possibly lead to bacterial-type life on other planets in the universe.

      But what about more complex life?

      The ‘eukaryotic’ cells that make up our bodies actually contain an interesting organelle within them. In the distant distant past this organelle may very well have lived independently – as separate bacteria. These bacteria-like cells, within our cells, are called mitochondria.

      Mitochondria are like little batteries that provide energy to our large and complex cells. And perhaps these batteries are what have allowed complex life to exist in the first place.

      Almost all eukaryotic cells have these batteries – mitochondria – and they are much more complex than bacteria. All multi-celled organisms are made from eukaryotic cells.

      So, maybe complex life requires two things. 1) the right chemistry to take place to make single cells, and 2) the chance event of the right cells meeting – so that one can become a battery for the other. Maybe this sort of chance event is less likely.

      This idea was discussed by Nick Lane – a biochemist – in the book ‘Power, Sex, Suicide – Mitochondria and the Meaning of Life’. If you are interested in the origins of life, then I would recommend reading this book!

      On the other hand, perhaps it is possible for complex life to arise in one or many other ways. It really is very hard to say. If anything is possible though, the universe is so large there is a very good possibly that somewhere it has happened!

      To summarise, I don’t know whether we’re alone in the universe either. It seems very unlikely that there are no single celled organisms out there. Complex life though? Hard to say! But I like to think so :).

    • Photo: Robert Hampson

      Robert Hampson answered on 17 Nov 2014:


      In 1961, Frank Drake (an American astronomer and astrophysicist) created what is known as the Drake equation. This equation is intended to summarise all the things which are likely to affect the probability of intelligent civilizations in our galaxy (the Milky Way) and allow us to estimate the likelihood of us detecting these civilizations.

      The equation is:
      (Number of civilizations in Milky Way)=(Average rate of star formation in galaxy)x(Fraction of stars with planets)x(Average number of potential life supporting planets per star with planets)x(Fraction of potentially life supporting planets that actually produce life at some point in time)x(Fraction of planets with life which eventually produce intelligent life)x(Fraction of civilizations which produce detectable signals)x(Length of time the average civilization produces these signals for)

      Most of the terms are incredibly difficult to even estimate. In 1961, Drake and his colleagues estimated the minimum answer at 20 detectable civilizations in the Milky Way.

      This eventually led to further thinking which resulted in what is known as the Fermi Paradox. The quoted definition of the paradox is “The apparent size and age of the universe suggest that many technologically advanced extraterrestrial civilizations ought to exist. However, this hypothesis seems inconsistent with the lack of observational evidence to support it.” In other words, our best guesses suggest there should be other easily contactable life out there, why can’t we find any evidence of them.

      Solutions to the paradox include:
      1) Intelligent civilizations are deliberately undetectable (they don’t want to be found)
      2) Intelligent civilizations take a long time to develop and our galaxy is quite young (In other words, we’re the first, we’re waiting for others to appear)
      3) Our estimates for the various constants to the Drake equation are wrong (Reasons could include intelligent civilizations killing themselves or dying out surprisingly quickly, life being less likely than estimated, it being very difficult to communicate/detect/travel over the required distances because we don’t know much about interstellar space, etc.)

      I read a series of science fiction books by C.S. Lewis once (a Christian author from WW2 and a while after). He specifically dealt with option 1. He wrote a story where God had created other civilizations but they didn’t talk to us because we were a fallen planet who disobeyed God.

      So as you can see, many people have thought of this and no one really knows the answer though there is a lot of material for really great stories!!

      Everyone loves E.T. !

    • Photo: Marikka Beecroft

      Marikka Beecroft answered on 19 Nov 2014:


      Who knows! How cool would it be though if we weren’t?

Comments